THE RISE OF THE CURATOR / FALL OF THE CRITIC

THE RISE OF THE CURATOR / FALL OF THE CRITIC

How the celebrity curator is taking over the art world  

by Jamie Tennent

In the art market today, there’s one question that keeps being asked: “What is the purpose of the gallery?” A challenging space for new ideas, a platform for voices yet unheard, a place for discussion and shifting paradigms or, in our ‘entrepreneurial society’ another money making venture to sell a lifestyle?

For whatever reason, be it a post Reagan-era shift in attitudes or relentless cuts to arts funding, the latter is what we’re being left with. Scores of galleries are gradually becoming new exercises in celebrity branding – the MoMA exhibited Bjork’s work to get crowds lining up behind a name we can all recognise. In the world of financial risk analysis, why give a platform to a new name when an old one will bring the best returns.

The Pompidou Centre received big crowds and a lot of press (good and bad) for its Jeff Koon Retrospective.

The curator, ever the retiring figure organising behind the scenes, is now the figure head of the theme-park exhibit – the roller coaster might be exciting but you know you’ll never get hurt. In a survey by Frieze, Iwona Blazwick, critic and director of the Whitechapel Art Gallery summed up this new role: “The last 40 years have marked the rise and proliferation of curators, collectors and architects specializing in making museums into powerful corporate brands that are intended to provide mass entertainment, generate tourism or solve social problems.”

Klaus Biesenbach, director of MoMA and the curatorial eye behind the Bjork retrospective, that took 15 years to produce, won’t lose his job. As much as the press protested, the queues snaked “out of the door and down the block” and when the gallery is a business, it’s numbers that matter.

MoMA’s Björk Retrospective Disaster, curated by Klaus Biesenbach (Right).

Losing a curator like Biesenbach, however maligned, can be detrimental to a gallery too. The curator is now a celebrity in his own right, he has an international network and a social media fan base of his own. If Hans-Ulricht Obrist instagrams the show, 94,000 people know about it straight away.

Here is where the critic should come in, acting as the arbitrator between the business and art, between the money and the substance, but critics no longer hold the place they did. Dave Hickey said the good ones died out: “Most of my younger colleagues, the art critics who should be in the ascendant today, died of AIDS in the 1980s. Those that survive are academics or tabloid celebrity geeks”, but that’s not the whole story.

Respected art critic, Dave Hickey said he quit the art world because “It’s no longer fun or honorable and had become an industry full of art dealers, curators, academics and PR driven critics whose jobs now lie in maintaining, if not inflating, the value of investments and playing it safe for.”

Technology has made the critical space so accessible that it’s hard to know who to listen to. With company’s desperation to ‘trend’ we’re all expected to come up with an opinion and share it worldwide – and why should a company listen to the critics when the audience it wants flooding between its doors are yelling out what they want to see, hashtagged and ready to search.

In his book, ‘Ways of Seeing’ Ossian Ward wrote this: “With so many voices and visuals competing for our attention, it’s a wonder that that we can filter out any sense in our daily existence at all, especially given our near-continuous interactions with the internet, the television, the smartphone, the social media timeline and the 24-Hour news stream, not to mention the general claxons and clamour of city noise. More than ever before, looking has become a matter of Darwinian survival. Only the strongest images make the grade”. This image-driven culture has led us down a dangerous route, there are a lot of media entities that won’t take a story, however interesting or well written, if it doesn’t come with engaging imagery. The public isn’t looking for the newest subtle ideas, they’re looking for the big pictures that entice them to click. For the MoMA, it was the big name.

Now, the artist shouldn’t be just be ‘artistic’ – using that word carefully – but to get a show exhibited they should be a rock-star, filling us with social media awe. Are we interested in the thought behind Damien Hirst’s crystal skull or are we just interested in it being a crystal skull?

Tate Modern's Damien Hirst Retrospective was the most visited solo show in the gallery's history. Artwork: A Thousand Years by Damien Hirst.

So what should our galleries stand for? The anti-elitist in me says that they are our galleries, they should be there to engage the public and that listening to this new public voice is an important part of bringing the gallery space out of the hands of the few. Surely good ticket sales mean galleries are acting as a more democratic space, not run and lauded over by the select in-crowd? But when the driving force behind exhibits are ticket sales, emerging artists lose out and exploration of new ideas risk coming to fruition.

In our current best-seller art world scene, the curator has become a cultural superstar responsible for bring in the crowd, leaving the gallery exhibition to become rife for glitter PR backed entertainment looking to impress a mass audience in search for a quick fix. With less room for innovation, is the rise of "star curator" a marking of the end of any possible avant-garde?

 

 

Leave a comment

Please note: comments must be approved before they are published.

90'S GRUNGE WEIGHS IN ON FASHION

Smudged lipstick, lolita-esque nighties, & ripped stockings, ready to confuse & disturb

Chloe Mackey

Read more »
Share »

A SEXLESS SOCIETY IS HERE

Fashion rides the gender blending trend  

Maria Raposo

Read more »
Share »

THE HEDI SLIMANE EFFECT ON YVES SAINT LAURENT

How the designer remade the house of Yves Saint Laurent

Greg French

Read more »
Share »

NAN GOLDIN: THE BALLAD OF SEXUAL DEPENDENCY

The artist captures the essence of humanity and life on the edge

Ellie Howard

Read more »
Share »

SYNCHRODOGS: “I must be dreaming”

We speak to the photography duo about synchronicity & the power of dreams

Ellie Howard

Read more »
Share »

MEET THE ARTISTS CHINA CAN'T KEEP CONTAINED

Artists Sun Yuan & Peng Yu use dead babies & live animals in their creations to blur the lines of art & reality

Peter Yeung

Read more »
Share »

JOSEPH BEUYS: I LIKE AMERICA AND AMERICA LIKES ME

What we can learn from artist about race relations and how to heal a nation    

Peter Yeung

Read more »
Share »

THE COLLAGE RENAISSANCE

Contemporary collage is the new Pop Art collectors are buying into

Harriet Baker

Read more »
Share »

DAVID BOWIE PUSHED THE LIMITS OF MUSIC, ART & FASHION

Bowie was an artist and an explorer that embodied true individuality that our generation craves

Fiona Ma

Read more »
Share »

FASHION PHOTOGRAPHY GETS HYPER-REAL

From Erwin Blumenfeld to Nick Knight, fashion constructs fantastical images

Greg French

Read more »
Share »

90'S GRUNGE WEIGHS IN ON FASHION

Smudged lipstick, lolita-esque nighties, & ripped stockings, ready to confuse & disturb

Chloe Mackey

Read more »
Share »

A SEXLESS SOCIETY IS HERE

Fashion rides the gender blending trend  

Maria Raposo

Read more »
Share »

THE HEDI SLIMANE EFFECT ON YVES SAINT LAURENT

How the designer remade the house of Yves Saint Laurent

Greg French

Read more »
Share »

NAN GOLDIN: THE BALLAD OF SEXUAL DEPENDENCY

The artist captures the essence of humanity and life on the edge

Ellie Howard

Read more »
Share »

SYNCHRODOGS: “I must be dreaming”

We speak to the photography duo about synchronicity & the power of dreams

Ellie Howard

Read more »
Share »

MEET THE ARTISTS CHINA CAN'T KEEP CONTAINED

Artists Sun Yuan & Peng Yu use dead babies & live animals in their creations to blur the lines of art & reality

Peter Yeung

Read more »
Share »

JOSEPH BEUYS: I LIKE AMERICA AND AMERICA LIKES ME

What we can learn from artist about race relations and how to heal a nation    

Peter Yeung

Read more »
Share »

THE COLLAGE RENAISSANCE

Contemporary collage is the new Pop Art collectors are buying into

Harriet Baker

Read more »
Share »

DAVID BOWIE PUSHED THE LIMITS OF MUSIC, ART & FASHION

Bowie was an artist and an explorer that embodied true individuality that our generation craves

Fiona Ma

Read more »
Share »

FASHION PHOTOGRAPHY GETS HYPER-REAL

From Erwin Blumenfeld to Nick Knight, fashion constructs fantastical images

Greg French

Read more »
Share »

THE EVOCATIVE IMAGES OF STREET PHOTOGRAPHY

Eminent street photographers find beauty in the ordinary

Leah Sinclair

Read more »
Share »

THE ZINE SCENE IS BACK

Self-Publishing is Having a Moment and It’s Redefining Youth and Self Expression

Leah Sinclair

Read more »
Share »

PLASTIC PURGERY – BARBIE IN BONDAGE BREAKS THE INTERNET

Photographer Mariel Clayton Reinvents the Stereotype of the Female Form

Fiona Ma

Read more »
Share »

LOUIS VUITTON - SERIES 3 EXHIBITION

Nicolas Ghesquière: less mask, more man

Greg French

Read more »
Share »

REGENERATION OR GENTRIFICATION?

The changing face of London’s artistic communities

Peter Yeung

Read more »
Share »

INSIDE THE CHELSEA HOTEL

The legendary New York hangout of rockstars and Hollywood royalty

Ellie Howard

Read more »
Share »

IN CONVERSATION WITH OLAF BREUNING

The artist talks about the endless interpretations of his work and life

Ellie Howard

Read more »
Share »

REVEALED: KURT COBAIN'S ORIGINAL ARTWORK

A dark look into the mind of Nirvana’s tortured frontman

Daryl Mersom

Read more »
Share »

ABOUT A GIRL: TEENAGERS IN POP CULTURE

Exploring media fantasies from saints to bad-ass sinners of female youth

Leah Sinclair

Read more »
Share »

ART GONE VIRAL

Performance art videos are paving the way for activism through social media

Leah Sinclair

Read more »
Share »

IN CONVERSATION WITH ARTIST TOM LEAMON

The ritual experiments of painting and poetry

Ellie Howard

Read more »
Share »

COLLAGE ARTIST HOLLY-ANNE BUCK/COLLAGISM

We talk to the artist about playing with abstraction & reconstructing reality

Ellie Howard

Read more »
Share »

FROM UNISEX TO ANTI-FASHION

Meet Rudi Gernreich, the first gender blender fashion activist

Alessandro Esculapio

Read more »
Share »

THE REVIVAL OF WARP N’ WEFT

From artisan to art; the lost craft of tapestry is making a comeback

KOD Staff

Read more »
Share »

THE ALCHEMY OF COLLAGE: ARTISTS IRINA & SILVIU SZEKELY

Art is not art if it doesn’t generate misrepresentation, confusion, anger or sarcasm

Ellie Howard

Read more »
Share »

THE CREATIVE CLASS: MAKING IT THEIR WAY

Photographer Francesca Allen captures the talented, genuine and real

KOD Staff

Read more »
Share »

'80S ICON KEITH HARING’S POP SHOP

The Art and Commerce of Giving Back

Alessandro Esculapio

Read more »
Share »

THE DEATH OF BRONSON

The art and literature of "Charles Bronson"; Britain's most notorious prisoner

KOD Staff

Read more »
Share »

THE PSYCHEDELIC LOVE-IN OF THE FABULOUS COCKETTES

San Francisco’s original underground glitter troupe

KOD Staff

Read more »
Share »

THE MODERN DAY DANDY CULT

Old fashioned values and classic sartorial style returns to mens fashion

Ellie Howard

Read more »
Share »
Top